The “invisible hand” of peer review: The implications of author-referee networks on peer review in a scholarly journal

作者:

Highlights:

• We estimated network positions of 2232 author/referee couples in an interdisciplinary journal..

• Referees tended to recommend more positively submissions by authors who were closer in their collaboration networks.

• Co-authorship network positions changed after peer review: respective distances decreased more rapidly than could have been expected by chance.

• Findings suggest that peer review could not only reflect but also create and accelerate scientific collaboration patterns.

摘要

•We estimated network positions of 2232 author/referee couples in an interdisciplinary journal..•Referees tended to recommend more positively submissions by authors who were closer in their collaboration networks.•Co-authorship network positions changed after peer review: respective distances decreased more rapidly than could have been expected by chance.•Findings suggest that peer review could not only reflect but also create and accelerate scientific collaboration patterns.

论文关键词:Peer review,Author-referee networks,Co-authorship network,Collaboration,Scholarly journals

论文评审过程:Received 18 October 2018, Revised 26 March 2019, Accepted 27 March 2019, Available online 5 April 2019, Version of Record 5 April 2019.

论文官网地址:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joi.2019.03.018